Published online in the Australian Financial Review on 8 November 2026: https://www.afr.com/world/north-america/netanyahu-s-exit-is-what-israel-needs-to-reset-us-ties-after-blue-wave-20261108-p61c7y, and published in print on 9 November 2026, p. 31.
“We are never going to have a President like Donald Trump again.” For Republicans, those words turned sour last Tuesday with the Democrat Blue Tsunami. For the Grand Old Party, the recriminations for the mid-term humiliation will define the decades ahead. The consequences for Israel are grave.
This is because recalibration of the Israel-US relationship is well underway. And Benjimin Netanyahu is getting blamed for the dramatically negative shifts in Israel-US relations.

A noisy minority of anti-Israel Democratic Socialists of America, infiltrators in the Democratic Party with representation in Congress, will seek to tilt the “special relationship”, with substantially limited military aid.
Netanyahu and Israelis now need to reset the relationship with the Democrats. Netanyahu assiduously and solely cultivated Republicans; his brand is toxic amongst Democrats.
After Netanyahu’s coalition lost its majority at last month’s Knesset election, Israeli president Issac Herzog has given opposition candidate and former military chief Gadi Eisenkot an initial mandate to form a government following marathon discussions with party leaders.
A new Israeli leader will have an easier time winning friends in the American political scene.
How this plays out remains to be seen. But on the Republican right, previously subdued critical voices are now loud and clear.
Vice President J.D. Vance on “X” nominated four top reasons for the mid-term election rout: 1) the Iran war; 2) the cost of living/inflation; 3) the neglect of the Put America First agenda; 4) the relationship to Israel. Citing feedback from pollsters, Vance says: “Our voters showed up. And the above four reasons are why many of them voted for Democrats.”
All four issues relate to Israel and its leader Bibi Netanyahu, who has extolled the line that there has never been a US President as staunchly pro-Israel as Trump. Now both leaders are emasculated, with a new Israeli prime minister likely to be sworn in by the end of the year.
Vance has been a known sceptic about the war with Iran since its commencement and wants it ended. Trump promised in 2024 there would be no more forever wars. But all year the President and his lightweight Secretary of War, Pete Hegseth, have been incoherent about the objectives and about American and its allies’ capability to thwart the Iranians.
Last year was different. The twelve-day US/Israel-Iranian war from 13 to 24 June 2025 had clear, limited objectives: destroy Iran’s nuclear capacity and seriously damage Iran’s projection of power in the region. The Iranian Airforce and air-defence capabilities were largely destroyed.
In June 2025, the UN’s International Atomic Energy Agency estimated Iran had acquired enough enriched uranium to produce nine nuclear warheads. This did not necessarily mean nuclear bomb production was imminent; it only meant that the capacity existed. Israel deemed this capacity unacceptable. Mid last year, American bunker-busting bombs were thought to have obliterated it.
But this second Iran war is another story. The on-gain, off-gain second war that began on 28 February this year is a mess. Regime change was touted as an objective, but this has not materialised nor seriously enabled (such as arming the Kurds, etc).
The wiping out of the Iranian leadership on the first day of the conflict was precise and impressive. But more dogmatic, difficult hardliners are now in charge. Iran’s ability to damage the American allies in the region including American military bases in Qatar, Bahrain, the Gulf States, and beyond, has been extensive. This surprised the Pentagon. As did Iran’s effective blockade of the Straits of Hormuz.
Failure to think through potential consequences wrongfooted the Americans. Oil and diesel prices spiked adding to American economic and inflationary pressures. Voters revolted. Vance is not alone on the MAGA right in thinking that Trump and the American administration were gulled by the Israelis to under-estimate Iranian capabilities to damage American stakes in the region. Vance believes that American interests significantly diverge from Israel’s and that America should act accordingly.
This mindset is predicated on the notion that America First means a ruthless calculation of doing what benefits America. On this reasoning, going to war for Israel is not America First. Narrowly interpreted it means there are no allied nation states, only vassals, clients and enemies. This worldview also underpins the philosophy of Trump’s tariffs.
Anti-Canadian tariffs badly hurt American industry in the Great Lakes States. This was a contributing factor in last Tuesday’s result in Michigan and Minnesota. The Canadian and American economies are intricately intertwined. The prices for vital goods for American businesses went up. This was an own goal for the administration.
More significant is the growing view on the MAGA Right that Trump was led by the nose by Netanyahu to join a futile conflict.
That this is absurd is beside the point. Trump needed little persuasion. Yet the claim is widely believed. Trump’s easy victory in Venezuela made him think regime change was easy. He is not the first President to under-estimate the Iranians or to overestimate Pax America.
Notwithstanding Trump’s endorsement and boost to Netanyahu’s fortunes in the recent Israeli elections, which highlighted their closeness, now that the Democrats will run the U.S. Senate for the next six years, Netanyahu is a liability for Israel.
It was always going to get worse for US-Israel ties if he remains in charge.
How the article appeared in the paper:
